02/09/2020

2 September 2020
2 September 2020, Comments Comments Off on ADAC performs motorhome crash test
ADAC performs motorhome crash test

ADAC, the motoring organisation in Germany, has performed a head-on crash test simulation between a motorhome (van conversion) and a car to see how safe a motorhome is if it is loaded according to regulations.

In the crash test, the mobile home hit an estate car head-on at 56 km/h (35mph). The result of the crash showed that the crumple zones of both vehicles were overwhelmed. The ADAC says that the front of the motorhome is not optimally designed to absorb the energy of the impact and the crumple zone of the car alone is not up to the fully-loaded motorhome, which is twice as heavy (3.5 tons). 

The passenger cells of both vehicles were damaged and the pedals were pushed far into the footwell, representing a very high risk of injury for the drivers of both vehicles. 

The ADAC says that manufacturers of mobile homes, regardless of whether they are based on a car or a commercial vehicle, must design the front of the vehicle in such a way that the energy of the impact is dissipated in the crumple zone, and the passenger cell must remain stable as a survival space.

According to the results of the ADAC crash, not only the driver, but also the rear passengers in the motorhome are exposed to a high risk of injury. This is mainly due to the design of the rear seat, which in most motorhomes is only made of thin wood: in the event of an impact, the rear seat collapses and the heads of those sitting at the rear (in the test crash: a child dummy in a child seat and an adult dummy) can hit the driver’s seat and the risk of injury to the abdomen increases. 

The ADAC says that substructure of the bench in the second row of seats must be improved so it is stable and does not collapse under the occupants in the event of an accident. This is the only way to prevent the belt slipping from the stable pelvis into the sensitive abdominal cavity and causing internal injuries. It is also important to avoid pads that are too thick or too soft, as this also increases the risk of the lap belt slipping and causing serious injuries.

Regarding the fixtures in the motorhome: the two double beds, bathroom, cupboards in the rear and the lashing eyes in the rear storage area did withstand the stresses of the impact – they and the luggage stored did not pose a risk to passengers. The safety equipment of the gas system also worked and interrupted the supply in the event of an accident, to minimise the risk of fire. However, the cabinets in the kitchen unit and their contents flew through the interior of the motorhome in the impact and endanger the occupants. In the mobile home tested, they were only connected to each another with a few screws and not to the chassis. As the crash test shows, this is not enough. Here, more stability and a connection with the vehicle should be ensured, says the ADAC.

The test also showed that holidaymakers in motorhomes can do a lot to increase safety: it is best to store heavy loads in the separate rear storage area, securing particularly heavy items of luggage down with tension straps. It is best to use light plastic dishes for the kitchen and not leave anything exposed while driving. To avoid injuries, the table in front of the rear row of seats must be dismantled or folded away. As with a car, all occupants should keep seat belts on. Anyone who buys or rents a motorhome should pay attention to emergency braking and lane keeping assistants. Although these cannot prevent every accident, they significantly reduce the risk of accidents.

A video of the test can be viewed here: https://youtu.be/tooRiJHt210